March 18, 2022

Ep. 171 True Crime: The Murders of Janice Pietropola and Lynn Seethaler

Last week was… a lot. We had Women Tell All and the Fantasy Suites. Because of the way things ended with the Fantasy Suites episode, Megan decided to base a story on Susie, who is from Virginia Beach, Virginia. There were several options for stories to choose from, and we put it to a vote on our Instagram stories, and this is the option chosen by YOU!

Janice Pietropola and Lynn Seethaler were two young women who just wanted a girl's week at the beach. When they didn’t return home to Pittsburgh, their families started to get worried, and when a hotel employee walked into their room, they were met with an absolutely horrifying scene. This story occurs in 1973 but has updates as recent as December 2021. (Story Starts at: 6:03)

CONTENT WARNING: Sexual assault

You can always connect with us at: There you can see links to our podcast and social media platforms.

You can support the podcast by becoming a Patreon Member at: We have several levels of membership, and we truly love you, mean it.

Always feel free to email us at: Send us true crime story suggestions and any questions or comments you may have.

--- Support this podcast: