True Crime Episodes

True Crime Bonus Content

BONUS EPISODE True Crime: Kids Who Kill Crossover with The Shit Show True Crime Podcast, The Murder of Derrick Robie & The Murder of Makia Coney

Oct. 1, 2020

Danielle joined Talysa & Sarah from The Shit Show True Crime Podcast ( find them here! ), to talk about mom life and discuss kids who kill. Megan is on a cross country road trip, wish her safe travels! Sarah tells the story …

Guest: Shit Show True Crime Podcast
True Crime

Episode 39 True Crime: The Murder of Amie Harwick and the Murder of Laurie Show

Sept. 24, 2020

This week we both cover cases involving stalking, due to the recent allegations made by Cassie Randolph against Colton Underwood (The Bachelor Seasons 23). First and foremost we need to say that on this podcast we believe wo…

True Crime

Episode 38 True Crime: The Controversial Fabulous Moolah

Sept. 17, 2020

Demi Burnett, from The Bachelor Season 23 (Colton Underwood) and Bachelor in Paradise Season 6, appeared on WWE Monday Night Raw on August 3, 2020. Danielle and her family are huge WWE fans, therefore her story is surroundin…

True Crime

Episode 37 True Crime: The Murder of Andrés Escobar and The Murder of Monica Spear and Thomas Berry

Sept. 10, 2020

This week on the GOAT was Juan Pablo Galavis. Juan Pablo was the soccer star single dad from Venezuela. He was the first Latinx lead the show has ever had. Megan covers the murder of Andrés Escobar, the Colombian soccer star…

True Crime

Episode 35 True Crime: The Murder of Kim Groves, Operation Shattered Shield and The Murder of Jun Lin

Sept. 3, 2020

This week on the GOAT was Nick Viall, who’s Megan’s favorite Bachelor. Megan talked about a few facts about him in Episode 22 (listen here ). The theme of these crimes we discuss is BOLD AND PROBLEMATIC. Danielle’s story is …

True Crime

The Murder of Sherrice Iverson - A Patreon Exclusive

Sept. 2, 2020

This is a sneak peek of our September 2020 BONUS True Crime Content, the Murder of Sherrice Iverson. CONTENT WARNING: This case involves the sexual assault and murder of a child. Sherrice Iverson was a beautiful 7-year-old c…

True Crime

Episode 33 True Crime: The Black Widow of Sacramento and the Seal Beach Salon  Massacre

Aug. 20, 2020

This was one of the first episodes we recorded, in a celebration of Clare Crawley who was announced as the Bachelorette for 2020… More info on that coming soon. In case you forgot (I mean, how could you??), Megan and Clare a…

True Crime

Episode 32 True Crime: The Murder of Keri Colleen “KC” Gauf, the Death of Alexander Beletsis and Other Greek Hazing Deaths

Aug. 13, 2020

This week we recapped Jason Mesnick’s season of the Bachelor, and the woman who got his final rose, Melissa Rycroft, was a former Dallas Cowboys cheerleader. Megan covers the story of the 2017 murder of Keri Colleen Gauf by …

True Crime

Episode 30: The Murders of Alison Parker and Adam Ward and the Massachusetts Drug Lab Scandal

Aug. 6, 2020

This week’s GOAT episode was all about Ali Fedotowsky! Ali was the 6th Bachelorette, circa 2010. Ali is from Massachusetts (Williamstown, specifically), and after her time as the Bachelorette, she went on to do some news cor…

True Crime

Episode 27 True Crime: The Murder of Abby Vandiver and the 2014 Isla Vista Killings

July 16, 2020

This week there was not a Bachelor GOAT episode but we still have a true crime Bachelor related episode for you! Danielle talks about the continued trauma that LaNease Adams and other Bachelor POC contestants have faced afte…

True Crime

Episode 26 True Crime: The First Recorded United States Trial The Manhattan Well Murder of Elma Sands and the Legends of Lavinia Fisher - the First Female Serial Killer in the United States

July 9, 2020

In honor of Alex being the first Bachelor and Trista being the first Bachelorette, we both took that theme of firsts and ran with it. Danielle discusses the first recorded trial in the United States, The Manhattan Well Murde…

True Crime

Episode 24: True Crime: The Honor Killings of Gelareh Bagherzadeh and Coty Beavers and the Murder of Muhlaysia Booker

July 2, 2020

This week’s episode is a little long but necessary and emotional, sorry not sorry. Megan focuses on the 2012 honor killings of Gelareh Bagherzadeh and Coty Beavers. She does a deep dive into what honor killings even are… whi…

True Crime

Episode 22 True Crime: The Murder of April Tinsley and the Exoneration of Nick Yarris

June 25, 2020

This week we discuss the murder of April Tinsley in Indiana, where Bachelor Ben Higgins is from, whose murder was solved decades later thanks to DNA technology (WARNING: This story involves the sexual assault and murder of a…

True Crime

Episode 20 True Crime: Peaches and Cherries Doe & the Murder of Robert Knox (from Harry Potter)

June 18, 2020

This week we discuss two high profile cases with a twist. Two unidentified victims with tattoos that lead to a notorious serial killer that is yet to be caught. We also talk about the murder of Robert Knox, who played Marcus…

True Crime

Episode 18 True Crime: Glacier Park Murder of Cody Lee Johnson and the London M25 Murder of Stephen Cameron

June 11, 2020

We’re rolling out a true crime news segment in order to help keep you up to keep you up to date on what’s happening around the world. This week’s Bachelor GOAT episode was a recap of Sean Lowe’s season… In this episode we ta…