True Crime Episodes

True Crime

The École Polytechnique Massacre March 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

March 1, 2021

This is a sneak peek of our March 2021 True CrimePatreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode here . Starting at the $3 level of our Patreon membership! March is Women’s history month! And in that vein, Megan tel…

True Crime

Episode 80 True Crime: Gallaudet University Murders of Eric Pluckett and Benjamin Varner

Feb. 26, 2021

Last week we saw Abigail be voted off the island (please ignore Danielle, you know her new obsession is Survivor). Abigail is the first deaf contestant to be on the show, we love to see ability diversity. This week Danielle …

True Crime

Episode 79 True Crime: Mysterious Death of Tamla Horsford

Feb. 25, 2021

Megan brings it back to Forsyth County, Georgia this week for this unsolved case. Tamla was a “supermom” of five boys, and a bonus mom to one daughter and the circumstances of her death are quite mysterious. She went to a bi…

True Crime

Episode 77 True Crime: The Fires of Paul Kenneth Keller, the Pyromaniac

Feb. 18, 2021

On week 5 of The Bachelor, Sarena C. called Katie out for all the drama she seemed to be inserting herself in. Sarena called Katie an arsonist and says she is setting little fires everywhere. Danielle tells the twisted story…

True Crime

Episode 75 True Crime: The History and Black Expulsion of Forsyth County, a Sundown Town

Feb. 12, 2021

Last week, we saw a 1-on-1 date with Rachael Kirkconnell, who now seems to be a front runner. Rachael is from Cumming, Georgia, in Forsyth County. Forsyth County has a long history of racial tensions, including running appro…

True Crime

Episode 74 True Crime: The Crime of Interracial Marriage, Loving vs. Virginia

Feb. 11, 2021

One week 5 of The Bachelor we saw Matt, our first black male lead, go on dates with racist Rachael and Kit. In reflecting on Black History Month, and the “progress” the ABC franchise has made with a POC lead, Danielle covers…

True Crime

Episode 72 True Crime: The Heist of Sweden’s Crown Jewels

Feb. 4, 2021

On last week’s episode, we saw the theft of a true Queen’s crown. It was a crime in it of itself. In this episode, Megan covers the 2018 heist of Sweden’s crown jewels by thieves who speed away on a boat, just like the movie…

True Crime Bonus Content

The Rosewood Massacre February 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

Feb. 1, 2021

This is a sneak peek of our February 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode here . Starting at the $1 level of our Patreon membership for the month of February! Happy Black History Month! Re…

True Crime

Episode 70 True Crime: The Murder of Helen Bailey… and Presumed Murder of Diane Stewart and the Death of Amy Joyner-Francis

Jan. 28, 2021

On week 2’s group date, the women wrote their own romance stories of their love story with Matt. Each story was HEAVY on the erotica, I might add. Because of that, Megan covers the story of a murdered author, Helen Bailey. H…

True Crime

Episode 68 True Crime: The Toxic Murders of Duane Johnson & Chad Shelton and the McStay Family Murders

Jan. 21, 2021

On week 2 of The Bachelor we saw Queen Victoria’s reign of toxic terror continue. Danielle gives us a definition of toxic behavior. She also tells the story of toxic love and murder and the first murder by cancer that took t…

True Crime

Episode 66 True Crime: The Murder of Faith Hedgepeth and the Story of the Most Hated Woman in America

Jan. 14, 2021

This week we cover stories based on Matt James’ premiere episode! Bachelor Matt James is originally from North Carolina, so Megan covers the story of the unsolved murder of Faith Hedgepeth. Faith was an Indigenous college st…

Bonus Content True Crime

Celia a Slave v. Missouri January 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

Jan. 2, 2021

This is a sneak peek of our January 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode starting at the $3 level of our Patreon page, link here . This episode we have our MOST favorite guests of all time…

True Crime Bonus Content

Tillie Klimek and the Joes January 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

Jan. 1, 2021

This is a sneak peek of our January 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode starting at the $3 level of our Patreon page, link here . This episode we have our MOST favorite guests of all time…

True Crime Guest Appearances

Episode 63 True Crime: The Crimes of John Michael Musbach and The Amityville Horror (With Special Guest Abi)

Dec. 30, 2020

We have a special guest this week! It’s Abi from Portal 8 Podcast ! Megan bases her story on Tayshia’s brand new fiancee, Zac Clark! Zac is originally from Haddonfield, New Jersey, and Megan found a story of an attempted mur…

Guest: Say Your Goodbyes Podcast
True Crime

Episode 60 True Crime: The Murder of Christopher Ross and The Life, Legacy, and Murder of Elvira Manahan

Dec. 21, 2020

Megan is STILL so upset about the fact that Riley did not receive a rose, so she based her story on him for the week! Riley is an attorney in New York, who went to law school at Syracuse University. Megan found a story from …