True Crime Episodes

True Crime

Episode 100 True Crime: The Padre Island Beach Camper Murders of James and Michelle Butler

June 17, 2021

Holy crap we cannot believe we have recorded 100 episodes! Thank you so much for your support over the last year-ish. We so very much appreciate you. And of course, we love you and definitely mean it. Last week was the Bache…

True Crime

Episode 98 True Crime: The Murder of Amanda “Mandy” Stavik

June 10, 2021

The Bachelorette is back! Danielle covers a story in the state of Washington, where Katie, the Bachelorette lead, is from. Before the story, Danielle shares a couple of updates about things going on with her life… There’s a …

Bonus Content True Crime

The Kansas City Butcher June 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

June 1, 2021

This is a sneak peek of our June 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode here . Starting at the $3 level of our Patreon membership! Danielle tells us about a serial killer she had never heard…

True Crime

Ep 96 True Crime: The Murder of Mark Carson

May 27, 2021

Welcome to our last, off season, true crime stories covering Taylor Nolan’s tweets. Danielle recaps all the stories we’ve covered, gives an announcement about the next Bachelor / True Crime schedule for the pod and covers a …

True Crime

Episode 95 True Crime: The Kidnapping of Shergar

May 20, 2021

Megan needed to take a break from the Taylor Nolan tweet series (who did she NOT offend!?!?!?). So, this week Megan tells the story of the Kidnapping of Shergar. Shergar was an incredibly fast and talented thoroughbred raceh…

True Crime

Episode 94 True Crime: The Red Summer of 1919

May 13, 2021

In the unending Taylor Nolan tweet series, this week Megan takes on Anti-Black Racism. While we’ve discussed this topic several times on the pod, the topic is important enough to be discussed again. Megan tells the story of …

True Crime

Episode 93 True Crime: The Murder of Priyadarshini Mattoo

May 6, 2021

We’re still talking about the groups that were attacked in Taylor Nolan’s tweets … and NO we are not done (slaps hand on face emoji). Taylor made some disgusting tweets about Indian people. This week Danielle is telling us a…

True Crime

Episode 92 True Crime: The Story of the Patriarca Crime Family AKA the New England Mafia

April 29, 2021

We’re still working through the communities that were attacked in Taylor Nolan’s tweets. This week, Danielle talks about Fat Shaming and Fatphobia. On that note, f**k people that fat shame, Bachelor give us a real size conte…

True Crime Guest Appearances

Episode 91 True Crime: The Story of Ernesto Miranda

April 22, 2021

This week Megan tells the Story of Ernesto Miranda, whose life has left a lasting impact on the criminal justice system in the United States. Megan has noticed a lot of Bachelor Nation lives in Arizona, and SEVERAL members o…

Guest: Kelcee
True Crime

Episode 90 True Crime: The Murder of Mary Phagan and the Lynching of Leo Frank

April 15, 2021

We’re still working through the communities that were attacked in Taylor Nolan’s tweets. This week, Megan focuses on the Jewish community and talks about Anti-Semitism around the world and in the United States. We jump in th…

True Crime

Episode 89 True Crime: The Murder of Gerlie Alpajora and the Disappearance of Keith Davis

April 8, 2021

We decided to cover stories that highlight the marginalized populations that were attacked in the recently resurfaced tweets by Taylor Nolan. This week, we focus on the Asian-American and Pacific Islander (AAPI) communities.…

True Crime

Episode 88 True Crime: The Murder of Blenda Gay

March 31, 2021

Megan wanted to connect one more story to Matt’s season of the Bachelor. This story is based on the fantastic host of After the Final Rose (ATFR), Emmanuel Acho. Emmanuel Acho was a linebacker in the National Football League…

True Crime

Episode 87 True Crime: The Crime of Cultural Appropriation: The story of Race Faker, Rachel Dolezal

March 25, 2021

This week we are connecting our true crime story to The Bachelor finale and After the Final Rose (ATFR). This season we saw a lot of problematic white women and racism all up and through this franchise. It all ended with Rac…

True Crime

Episode 86 True Crime: The West Nickel Mines School Shooting

March 18, 2021

This week is fantasy suites! Michelle’s date is a spa date that is themed after Pennsylvania Dutch Country, and Megan wanted to learn more about the Pennsylvania Dutch People, so she does just that. Megan tells the story of …

True Crime

Episode 84 True Crime: Breaking the Façade of Anna Delvey - the Crimes of Anna Sorokin

March 11, 2021

At the Women Tell All, some of the women were fake AF! Fake personalities and crocodile tears. So, Megan tells the story of another faker, Anna Delvey (aka Anna Sorokin). Anna posed as an heiress and lived in luxury in New Y…