True Crime Episodes

October 21, 2021

Episode 132 True Crime: The Murder of Jason Wilkman, Abduction of Mary and Elizabeth Stauffer

It is Michelle Young's Bachelorette premiere week and we are READY for our queen to grace our screens! Michelle (and Danielle) is from Minnesota, and Michelle is a teacher. So this week, Megan tells a story from Minnesota inv...

True Crime

October 14, 2021

Episode 130 True Crime: The Murder of Nia Haqq and Michael “Mike” Muchioki

On this episode we are joined by a special guest, our lady lawyer bestie and badass, Kelcee! She is filling in Megan, who is on vacation attending a family wedding. Last week we saw the three hour Bachelor in Paradise finale ...

True Crime

October 01, 2021

Episode 128 True Crime: Danziger Bridge Shootings - the Murders of James Brisette and Ronald Madison

Last week on Bachelor in Paradise, a tropical storm shut down the beach. This week, Megan tells the story of a shooting in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina that devastated New Orleans, Louisiana. The Danziger Bridge Shootin...

True Crime

September 20, 2021

Episode 125 True Crime: The Story of James Joseph Robinson

This week we are going to do it a little differently and we are going to tell you how Danielle connects this story to the Bachelor at the end of the episode. Just know, it is connected to all the Brenden / Pieper, relationshi...

True Crime

September 14, 2021

Episode 123 True Crime: The Murder of Paige Birgfield

Megan wanted to base a story on how Brendan was leading a double life, but this story twisted in a way that Megan was not expecting, so she went with it. Paige Birgfield was a loving single mother of three young kids who disa...

True Crime

September 09, 2021

Episode 122 True Crime: The Murder of Vicky Rose Miller

We are playing a little catch-up since Danielle has been sick. A couple of weeks ago, we saw two very problematic Victoria’s on our Bachelor in Paradise screen, with Victoria Paul and Victoria Larson. Thankfully they are both...

True Crime

September 07, 2021

The Assassination of John F. Kennedy: September 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

This is a sneak peek of our September 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode here , starting at the $3 level of our Patreon membership! Content Warning : Discussion of child death and stillbo...

Bonus Content True Crime

August 27, 2021

Episode 119 True Crime: The Murder of Deborah Gardner

Last week was the premiere of Season 7 of Bachelor in Paradise! So this week, Megan talks about a murder in Paradise. Deborah Gardner was a stunningly beautiful Peace Corps Volunteer, who was assigned to teach high school sci...

True Crime

August 19, 2021

Episode 117 True Crime: The Murder of Gladys Ricart

Last week, we saw the conclusion of the Bachelorette Season 17 with Katie Thurston as the lead. During the After the Final Rose (ATFR) we saw a heated conversation between Katie and Greg, it was the talk of Twitter. Some said...

True Crime

August 05, 2021

Episode 114 True Crime: The 1984 South Pasadena Arson Murders of Ada Deal, Matthew Troidl, Carolyn Kraus, and Jimmy Cetina

Last week at the Men Tell All, we saw one firefighter trainee just light it up on the stage. It felt like he got more air time at the MTA than all season long, so this one’s for you, Brendan. Megan tells the story of the 1984...

True Crime

August 02, 2021

The Murder of Kimberly Diane Leach, the Child Victim of Ted Bundy: August 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

This is a sneak peek of our August 2021 Bachelor Patreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode here . Starting at the $3 level of our Patreon membership! CONTENT WARNING : child sexual assault and child murder Dani...

True Crime Bonus Content

August 02, 2021

The Murder of Kimberly Diane Leach, the Child Victim of Ted Bundy: August 2021 True Crime Patreon Exclusive

This is a sneak peek of our August 2021 Bachelor Patreon Exclusive content. You can hear the full episode here . Starting at the $3 level of our Patreon membership! CONTENT WARNING : child sexual assault and child murder Dani...

True Crime Bonus Content

July 29, 2021

Episode 112 True Crime: The Aum Shinrikyo Cult and the 1995 Tokyo Subway Attack

Last week on The Bachelor, we saw a very strange date between the virgin, Mikey P. and Katie. They lay in the woods and are instructed to get intimate by a Cuddle Queen. Mikey P. and Katie are wearing all white in a weird cul...

True Crime

July 22, 2021

Episode 110 True Crime: Blue Ridge Savings Bank Murders

Last week we saw a couple of guest stars on a one-on-one date with Connor B, the Cat Man. One of those guest stars was Jason Tartick! Jason is a former contestant from Becca Kufrin’s season of the Bachelorette, now engaged to...

True Crime

July 15, 2021

Episode 108 True Crime: The Life and Death of Empress Elisabeth of Austria-Hungary

Last week we saw a one-on-one between Andrew S. and Katie (the blocker). The Bachelor wants us to believe that Andrew S. is from Vienna, Austria; when we know he is in fact from Chicago, Illinois. Danielle says “let’s keep it...

True Crime